[x]

deviantART

 

Google Chrome (Beta) First Impressions

Fri Sep 5, 2008, 12:05 PM
  • Mood: Nervous
  • Listening to: Primus - Bob
  • Watching: My bank account be cleared by my new apt's needs
  • Playing: Castle Crashers (360)/Magic the Gathering (TCG)
  • Drinking: Mintastic Tea by Kevin Rose
Since I've been using Google Chrome--Google's brand new internet browser--as my main browser for a few days, I thought I'd waste some time giving my early impressions of the software.

_What I Like
Google Chrome is fast. Very fast. It responds well and everything loads up fairly quick. This is in comparison to FireFox 3 (my main browser, normally), which is ALSO quick...just not THIS quick. In the real world, though, this gets to be splitting hairs. Your NEW computer, for instance, boots a lot faster than your OLD computer--but chances are after the first few times you don't notice the difference and go back to complaining about how long everything takes.

Google did a good job "borrowing" from other browsers. It has little features that I like about FireFox--namely the spell check feature. There's plans for additional "borrowed" features (see: Plugins), but that's not in this beta, so I can't comment. I suspect that once extensions are implemented, we'll see a flood of equally useful tools that us FireFox folks are so used to.

The last "What I Like" bit I want to mention is the overall interface. I like my browsers very minimalist, and Chrome delivers. Their mission statement was to make room for the content and I must say that it feels a little bit like Internet Explorer in Full Screen mode. The status messages on the bottom are out of the way and auto-hide, and the URL and web search fields have been combined in a way that just makes sense and keeps everything simple. Since they're combined, though, it does loose the ease of use of FireFox's web search that lets you easily pick from different search engines (so you could search Amazon.com one moment and Dictionary.com the next). Google doesn't HAVE to be your default search engine for these searches, but to change it you'd have to go through preferences.


_What I Hate
I realize that my previous authoritarian relationships have made me paranoid, but I LOVE that FireFox (and Internet Explorer for that matter) let me keep my history clear. I'm not requesting full-on "pr0n mode", I just want the option to make my history go away automatically. I don't like seeing a list of every site I've been to in the last month whenever I type a new URL in--at the very least because the auto-fill also keeps my typoed URLs so I get sent to the WRONG site over and over.

For the MORE paranoid, it also displays your top visited sites every time you open a new tab. So now your boss gets to notice that you come by MySpace perhaps a little too often. Joy.

Really, most of what I hate is just the LACK of options in the preference. They're even missing basics such as handling pop-ups. Google Chrome simply blocks all of them, and though you CAN open a blocked pop-up, you can't seem to set a site as "acceptable" like you can in other browsers. I listen to Pandora in pop-up mode a lot and I'm getting sick of retrieving my blocked pop-up every damn time.


_The Conclusion
Google Chrome will likely become my main browser once it works out it's bugs. It's not fair to compare a 3/4 day old browser that's in Beta to ones that have been out for years (see: FireFox 3), but Chrome needs to tackle more browser basics before I can suggest anyone switching over. But let's be clear, there's a LOT going for this new browser and everything it's missing is fairly minor and will likely be fixed in the next release.

Devious Comments

love 0 0 joy 0 0 wow 0 0 mad 0 0 sad 0 0 fear 0 0 neutral 0 0

I've been playing around with Chrome too. I like it. I just discovered the clear browser history stuff. . . but I think it deleted my pw's even though I told it not to. T_T

--
Tell them, dear
that if eyes were made for seeing,
then beauty is its own excuse for being.
You do realize that there's an Incognito window that it can open... so I don't see why you're complaining about keeping history clear in the "What You Didn't Like" section. It does about the same thing. You can also set the new tab to go to a blank page or something else everytime you open a new tab if you find the 10 most recently visited sites list inconvenient.
Incognito mode is TOO much. I need cookies to run still. Also, I shouldn't have to enter a special mode every damn time I surf the web. I only want browser history gone. I ran a similar mode to that in Firefox once (via and extension), and it removes TOO much and makes some websites unusable (for instance, you couldn't even log into some).

Also, I see nothing under the Google Chrome options to change what the new tab shows. Only what the homepage is.

--
-Andy Hayes





....Also, check out I Am Nerd.
I find most of these things that I have set up in Opera to handle, so I'm pretty happy with that. There's a reason why this isn't my first first choice. Sure Firefox is the usual default, but 90% of the time I'm in Opera.

Opera's Speed Dial tab is what opens up when you open a new tab, and it has 1-9 speed dials, which are settable. They look close to what the Chrome new tab looks like, just that the grid of sites are customizable. Furthermore, hitting Ctrl+num in any tab takes you to whatever speed-dial you set it to, so you don't need to open a new tab just to get to get to them.

I know what you mean about incognito rendering some sites unusable since they're cookie-dependent. I did try for a while to just disable all cookies in my browsers to see what'd happen, and surprise, some forums wouldn't let me login, or pretended to log me in but didn't, etc. It's a catch-22, you can't control how well sites are designed, but you can't control any one perfect way of handling privacy either. :/
That's why I'm just happy to auto-clear my history. I'm not really trying to prevent someone stalking me altogether.


My test computer here at work has just about every browser on it, btw. Even Safari for Windows. I never browse with it, though, so I don't play around with different browsers much.

--
-Andy Hayes





....Also, check out I Am Nerd.
I have... four browsers? Chrome, Opera, Firefox, IE (this one is clearly not by choice). I'm trying to go a week with Firefox replaced by Chrome to see how it goes. So far the only thing that seriously annoys me is that I don't have mouse gestures. Other than that, everything else is fairly acceptable. I guess I've always been a minimalist in that I never made use of many firefox plugins -- call me paranoid about security.

That's something annoying I've noticed about Chrome's browser history. You have the option to delete an entire day's worth of history, but not individual entries...
There is a mouse gesture extension for FireFox. I had it once, but I didn't find a real use for it. I'd assume they've updated it for use with FireFox 3.

--
-Andy Hayes





....Also, check out I Am Nerd.
Yeah, I know. I have that extension installed. I don't really make full use of it, I just like being able to rock my mouse buttons to go back instead of going up to the top of the screen to reach the back button. I'm lazy that way. And no, I don't have a fancy mouse with a back button already on it.
I don't really like Chrome, it's too much for my lower end comp.

Also, there is a "clear private data" button under the wrench, but that'll be annoying to open each time.

Also, any extensions you recommend for firefox? Mine's pretty stock and I don't feel I'm getting everything I could be getting out of it.

--
"If they can survive McDonalds they can certainly survive a stun gun." - ~FallisPhoto

:D

Journal History

Site Map